Topdog/Underdog
Fremont Centre Theatre
Reviewed by Jose Ruiz

It all started with Cain and Abel. Later in history, twin brothers Romulus and Remus made their mark and somewhere between 1599 and 1601 Shakespeare introduced King Hamlet and his brother Claudius.

In 2001, uber talented playwright Suzan-Lori Parks created two brothers named Lincoln and Booth for a play which she called Topdog/Underdog, nursing them to a Pulitzer Prize, while bringing about a story that has all the drama, agony and suffering of two young African American men as they struggle to survive in the turmoil of inner-city life.

Stephen Rider - Jed Reynolds

Director James Reynolds captures the essence of this life as he guides  Jed Reynolds and Stephen Rider in creating indelible characters that sear themselves into your mind. These actors don’t just perform their lines – they seem to actually live the torment and angst of their misery, sweeping the audience into the unforgiving abyss which will define their fate.

One wonders what callous mind would name his children Booth and Lincoln, but when we learn through their conversations that the father was a drunk and abandoned them when Lincoln was 16 and Booth 11 it becomes clear that their past was anything but joyful. Their mother had left them two years earlier, apparently with another man. Life forced Lincoln to become a card hustler, scamming people with a game of three-card monte which had kept him afloat until his best friend Lenny got killed in a scam gone bad. Though he was considered the best in the murky business, Lenny’s unexpected death made a deep impact which caused Lincoln to change his life and get a real job with benefits.

In the irony of ironies he finds a job in an arcade portraying Honest Abe Lincoln the evening he was shot by John Wilkes Booth. He dresses in white face, complete with top hat and beard as customers pay to rent a cap gun and pretend to shoot him in the balcony of Ford’s Theatre. Where before his greatest fear in life was getting busted for his scam, he now dreads that he may lose his job if he is replaced by a mannequin. Jed Reynolds creates a remarkable and compelling portrait of a man torn with indecision. Though he claims to fear the loss of his job, we feel his humiliation and loss of dignity as he portrays Lincoln in white face day in and day out. We can actually sense his vacillation about returning to the card scam, but we know that deep inside, the violent death of Lenny is still throbbing in his memory.

Booth, an accomplished petty thief by now, can’t wait to get into the card hustle. He practices the three-card monte daily, but knows he’ll never be as good as his older brother and begs Lincoln to train him. Stephen Rider brings out the complexities of the younger brother with amazing empathy and understanding. He is hot headed, impatient and willing to take any risk to accomplish what he wants. But we can feel the hurt he has suffered from his family - especially his mother, and his desperate search for some validation, some affection, some respect. Together, Rider and Reynolds make you laugh when they talk about their misguided relationships with women. They make you think when they discuss what may lie ahead in the uncertain future, and they often bring a discreet lump to your throat as you see them desperately grasping for an ever evaporating brass ring.

Suzan-Lori Parks created a prize winning play, so you know going in that the writing, the premise and the plot will be top notch. When you leave the theatre you know one more thing. You know that the Fremont Centre Theatre has created one of the most sensitive and excellent performances of this play, and it’s one that should be rated a “must see” by any discerning patrons of the theatre.

The play runs through September 18, 2010. Reservations at: (866) 811-4111 (Theatermania)

Online ticketing at: www.fremontcentretheatre.com

Comments? Write to us at: Letters@ReviewPlays.Com

                Photo by Carla Larissa Fallberg